This copycat McAlister’s club sandwich is perfect for lunch. Save time and money by making a delicious copycat version of your restaurant favorite at home!
This copycat McAlister’s club sandwich is a classic! It is sure to satisfy your McAlister’s cravings without leaving the house. Be sure to try it with a glass of this copycat McAlister’s sweet tea or a bowl of copycat McAlister’s tortilla soup.
Jump to:
Ingredients needed
For this sandwich, make note of the following:
- Bacon: I used the pre-cooked kind because that’s what I had on hand.
- Mayonnaise: I used Duke’s because a lot of restaurants use this brand.
- Honey mustard: I used a bottled one but you can make your own by combining two tablespoons of mayonnaise, two tablespoons of regular mustard, and two tablespoons of honey. Whisk well.
See my recipe card below for a complete list of the ingredients with measurements.
Recipe instructions (step by step guide)
Toast your bread in a toaster (or you can use your oven to do them all at once).
If you’re using regular bacon (I used the pre-cooked kind) fry your bacon and drain the fat the slices on paper towels. Set aside to cool.
Next, set aside three slices. Add mayonnaise and mustard to two slices of bread (Step #1).
Add one slice of Swiss cheese to one piece, one piece of cheddar to another, and the spring mix and sliced tomato to the last (Step #2).
Add bacon to one slice, turkey to another, and ham to the last (Step #3).
Place the slices on top of each other and cut into quarters. Add a toothpick to hold the sandwiches together (if desired, remove before eating).
Repeat directions to assemble the second sandwich.
Recipe FAQs
Store any leftover sandwiches in your fridge inside of an airtight container. I recommend only storing them for a day or two as they are best eaten immediately after making.
Yes, McAlister’s Deli uses a variety of breads for their sandwiches, including white, wheat, marble rye, croissants, and Ciabatta.
I recommend toasting the bread slices in the oven, over a toaster, which will substantially decrease preparation times.
Expert Tip
- I used Ken’s honey mustard but you can easily make your own by combining two tablespoons of mayonnaise, two tablespoons of regular mustard, and two tablespoons of honey. Whisk well.
Other Copycat McAlister’s Recipes:
If you tried this Copycat McAlister’s Club Sandwich Recipe or any other recipe on my website, please please leave a 🌟 star rating and let me know how you go in the 📝 comments below. I love hearing from you!
Copycat McAlister’s Club Sandwich
Equipment
- Toaster
Ingredients
- 6 slices wheat bread
- 1 tablespoon mayonnaise I used Duke's
- 1 tablespoon honey mustard
- 2 slices Swiss cheese
- 2 slices cheddar cheese
- 4 slices smoked turkey deli meat
- 4 slices black forest ham deli meat
- 6 slices bacon cut in half (I used precooked bacon)
- 1 Roma tomato sliced
- spring mix
Instructions
- Toast your bread in a toaster (or you can use your oven to do them all at once).
- If you're using regular bacon (I used the pre-cooked kind) fry your bacon and drain the fat the slices on paper towels. Set aside to cool.
- Next, set aside three slices. Add mayonnaise and mustard to two slices of bread.
- Add one slice of Swiss cheese to one piece, one piece of cheddar to another, and the spring mix and sliced tomato to the last.
- Add bacon to one slice, turkey to another, and ham to the last.
- Place the slices on top of each other and cut into quarters. Add a toothpick to hold the sandwiches together (if desired, remove before eating).
- Repeat directions to assemble the second sandwich.
Amy Liu Dong says
I love how easy and delicious to make this sandwiches, and I can’t wait to make this for everyone at home.